meeting-103 v2.1 clean R1 5/5: PuLID + Redux = pastel 48.5% (R9 best 갱신)

R0 환경 점검:
- VRAM 11.7/12.4GB free (94%) — 해소 확인
- pytorch 2.12.0+cu130 + sageattention venv 검증
- 모델 인벤토리: Flux Dev Q5 GGUF, PuLID, Redux, byeolyi-ref-916 확보
- fp8 다운로드 .part 0 bytes (재개 대기)

R1 clean 5조합 (5/5 success):
- 1-1: PuLID w0.85 mean → pastel 25.7% / black 1.95%
- 1-2: PuLID w0.85 mean delayed_start 0.05 → pastel 10.0% / black 14.0% (어두움)
- 1-3: PuLID w1.0 mean → pastel 27.5% / black 0.79%
- 1-4: PuLID w0.7 + Redux 0.5 → pastel 48.5% / black 0.27% ★ R1 best
- 1-5: 한옥 baseline Flux Dev 768² → pastel 12.9% / black 11.7%

CUDA error 회복:
- 1-2 retry concat → CUDA invalid argument → 후속 1-2~1-5 모두 실패
- ComfyUI venv 재시작 (sage + pytorch 2.12) → 1-2 변형 (delayed_start)로 대체
- 재시도 4/4 모두 success

이전 R9 best (44.5%) → R1-4 (48.5%) = +4 pp 갱신

자산 라이브러리 누적:
- models-performance.json: 7 모델 추적 (flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux 등)
- workflows: winner_auto 1 + partial 2
- prompts/proven: illustration_auto 패턴 3건
- prompts/failed: pastel-low + CUDA error 패턴
- prompts/negative: A_byeolyi 패턴 etc.

검수:
- Vault: D:\Vault\8460s-image-rd\eval\meeting-103-v2.1-clean-grid.html
- Gitea: results/meeting-103-v2.1-clean/round1/
This commit is contained in:
choijaewook
2026-05-19 23:17:19 +09:00
parent 3ffb52d04d
commit 6623ea4172
21 changed files with 1026 additions and 17 deletions

View File

@@ -65,10 +65,10 @@
},
"avg_scores": {},
"best_combinations": [],
"verdict": "7라운드 검증 / ComfyUI 재시작 후 100% 성공률 / 검정 0.01-0.68% 일관 / 파스텔 8-42% 변동"
"verdict": "파스텔 평균 26.1% (11회) / 검정 평균 0.24%"
},
"flux-dev": {
"rounds_used": 8,
"rounds_used": 22,
"dimensions": {
"byeolyi": [],
"hanja": [],
@@ -78,20 +78,56 @@
"auto_pastel": [
20.1,
29.7,
12.3
12.3,
9.99,
27.51,
48.5,
12.87,
25.65,
9.99,
27.51,
48.5,
12.87,
25.65,
9.99,
27.51,
48.5,
12.87
],
"auto_black": [
3.11,
0.0,
0.16
0.16,
13.98,
0.79,
0.27,
11.67,
1.95,
13.98,
0.79,
0.27,
11.67,
1.95,
13.98,
0.79,
0.27,
11.67
]
},
"avg_scores": {},
"best_combinations": [],
"verdict": "Stage 3 Refiner (img2img denoise 0.3) 정상 작동 / 단독 워크플로우는 OOM 빈번"
"best_combinations": [
{
"round": "R1-clean",
"id": "1-4",
"variant": "PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.5",
"pastel_pct": 48.5,
"black_pct": 0.27
}
],
"verdict": "파스텔 평균 24.1% (17회) / 검정 평균 5.14%"
},
"pulid-flux": {
"rounds_used": 9,
"rounds_used": 20,
"dimensions": {
"byeolyi": [],
"hanja": [],
@@ -101,12 +137,34 @@
"auto_pastel": [
30.2,
33.7,
44.5
44.5,
9.99,
27.51,
48.5,
25.65,
9.99,
27.51,
48.5,
25.65,
9.99,
27.51,
48.5
],
"auto_black": [
0.73,
2.51,
1.11
1.11,
13.98,
0.79,
0.27,
1.95,
13.98,
0.79,
0.27,
1.95,
13.98,
0.79,
0.27
]
},
"avg_scores": {},
@@ -119,9 +177,16 @@
"black_pct": 1.11,
"pastel_pct": 44.5,
"note": "전체 라운드 best pastel 1위"
},
{
"round": "R1-clean",
"id": "1-4",
"variant": "PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.5",
"pastel_pct": 48.5,
"black_pct": 0.27
}
],
"verdict": "weight 1.0 + mean fusion = 별이 ID lock + 파스텔 44.5% (R1-1 Pony 42.5% 추월)"
"verdict": "파스텔 평균 29.8% (14회) / 검정 평균 3.81%"
},
"qwen-image-2512": {
"rounds_used": 1,
@@ -150,7 +215,7 @@
},
"avg_scores": {},
"best_combinations": [],
"verdict": "단일 모델 성공 / A 별이 검정 13.92% 한계 / B 한옥 안정 36.4% 파스텔"
"verdict": "파스텔 평균 30.2% (2회) / 검정 평균 7.41%"
},
"qwen-edit-2511": {
"rounds_used": 8,
@@ -158,6 +223,40 @@
"avg_scores": {},
"best_combinations": [],
"verdict": "Stage 2 인페인트 6차 실패 — Qwen 계열 GGUF Q4 환경 호환성 결함 확정"
},
"flux-redux": {
"rounds_used": 3,
"dimensions": {
"byeolyi": [],
"hanja": [],
"hanok": [],
"illustration": [],
"korean_traditional": [],
"auto_pastel": [
48.5,
48.5,
48.5
],
"auto_black": [
0.27,
0.27,
0.27
]
},
"avg_scores": {},
"best_combinations": [
{
"round": "R1-clean",
"id": "1-4",
"variant": "PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.5",
"pastel_pct": 48.5,
"black_pct": 0.27
}
],
"verdict": "파스텔 평균 48.5% (3회) / 검정 평균 0.27%"
}
}
},
"_processed_rounds": [
"R1-clean"
]
}

View File

@@ -80,5 +80,15 @@
],
"verdict": "GGUF Q4 + CUDA 13.0 + PyTorch 2.12 환경 호환성 결함 — 6차 모두 5KB latent",
"next_track": "non-GGUF safetensors 또는 다른 quant (Q8/fp16) 필요 — 본 트랙에서는 한자 정확 렌더링 = Pony score_9 만 가능"
}
},
"r1-1-2-pastel-low-flux-dev": [
{
"round": "R1-clean",
"id": "1-2",
"variant": "PuLID weight 0.85 mean delayed_start 0.05 (concat-replacement)",
"pastel_pct": 9.99,
"black_pct": 13.98,
"note": "auto-classified pastel-low (delayed start_at + concat replacement)"
}
]
}

View File

@@ -1 +1,9 @@
{}
{
"A_byeolyi_pastel_negatives": [
{
"round": "R1-clean",
"negative": "cartoon, anime, child, teenage, purple hoodie, japanese building, plastic skin",
"resulted_in_pastel": 48.5
}
]
}

View File

@@ -23,5 +23,44 @@
"consistent_pastel_pct_range": "13-42% (해상도·프롬프트 영향)",
"verdict": "Pony 단일 모델 = 가장 안정적 (R1·R2·R4 모두 성공)"
}
},
"illustration_auto": {
"R1-clean-1-1": [
{
"pastel_pct": 25.65,
"black_pct": 1.95,
"variant": "PuLID weight 0.85 mean (first try)",
"models": [
"flux-dev",
"pulid-flux"
],
"round": "R1-clean"
}
],
"R1-clean-1-3": [
{
"pastel_pct": 27.51,
"black_pct": 0.79,
"variant": "PuLID weight 1.0 mean",
"models": [
"flux-dev",
"pulid-flux"
],
"round": "R1-clean"
}
],
"R1-clean-1-4": [
{
"pastel_pct": 48.5,
"black_pct": 0.27,
"variant": "PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.5",
"models": [
"flux-dev",
"pulid-flux",
"flux-redux"
],
"round": "R1-clean"
}
]
}
}

View File

@@ -1,5 +1,65 @@
{
"count": 0,
"winner": [],
"partial": []
"count": 3,
"winner": [
{
"name": "winner_auto-illustration_auto-R1-clean-1-4-flux-dev.json",
"category": "winner_auto",
"best_dimension": "illustration_auto",
"auto_metrics": {
"pastel_pct": 48.5,
"black_pct": 0.27
},
"models": [
"flux-dev",
"pulid-flux",
"flux-redux"
],
"round": "R1-clean",
"variant": "PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.5",
"reusable_for": [
"타로 78장",
"별이 일러스트 시리즈"
]
}
],
"partial": [
{
"name": "partial-illustration_auto-R1-clean-1-1-flux-dev.json",
"category": "partial",
"best_dimension": "illustration_auto",
"auto_metrics": {
"pastel_pct": 25.65,
"black_pct": 1.95
},
"models": [
"flux-dev",
"pulid-flux"
],
"round": "R1-clean",
"variant": "PuLID weight 0.85 mean (first try)",
"reusable_for": [
"관찰",
"한복 ref 후보"
]
},
{
"name": "partial-illustration_auto-R1-clean-1-3-flux-dev.json",
"category": "partial",
"best_dimension": "illustration_auto",
"auto_metrics": {
"pastel_pct": 27.51,
"black_pct": 0.79
},
"models": [
"flux-dev",
"pulid-flux"
],
"round": "R1-clean",
"variant": "PuLID weight 1.0 mean",
"reusable_for": [
"관찰",
"한복 ref 후보"
]
}
]
}

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,165 @@
{
"1": {
"class_type": "UnetLoaderGGUF",
"inputs": {
"unet_name": "flux1-dev-Q5_K_S.gguf"
}
},
"2": {
"class_type": "DualCLIPLoader",
"inputs": {
"clip_name1": "clip_l.safetensors",
"clip_name2": "t5xxl_fp8_e4m3fn.safetensors",
"type": "flux"
}
},
"3": {
"class_type": "VAELoader",
"inputs": {
"vae_name": "ae.safetensors"
}
},
"4": {
"class_type": "CLIPTextEncode",
"inputs": {
"text": "A 25-28 year old Korean woman in a modern hanbok with subtle Cute Horror mood, sitting gracefully in a traditional Korean tea house with hanok wooden architecture, warm afternoon light filtering through latticed windows, cool pale skin, gentle expression, photorealistic, high detail",
"clip": [
"2",
0
]
}
},
"5": {
"class_type": "CLIPTextEncode",
"inputs": {
"text": "cartoon, anime, child, teenage, purple hoodie, japanese building, plastic skin",
"clip": [
"2",
0
]
}
},
"6": {
"class_type": "EmptyLatentImage",
"inputs": {
"width": 768,
"height": 1344,
"batch_size": 1
}
},
"7": {
"class_type": "PulidFluxModelLoader",
"inputs": {
"pulid_file": "pulid_flux_v0.9.1.safetensors"
}
},
"8": {
"class_type": "PulidFluxEvaClipLoader",
"inputs": {}
},
"9": {
"class_type": "PulidFluxInsightFaceLoader",
"inputs": {
"provider": "CUDA"
}
},
"10": {
"class_type": "LoadImage",
"inputs": {
"image": "byeolyi-ref-768x1344.png"
}
},
"11": {
"class_type": "ApplyPulidFlux",
"inputs": {
"model": [
"1",
0
],
"pulid_flux": [
"7",
0
],
"eva_clip": [
"8",
0
],
"face_analysis": [
"9",
0
],
"image": [
"10",
0
],
"weight": 0.85,
"start_at": 0.0,
"end_at": 0.8,
"fusion": "mean",
"fusion_weight_max": 1.0,
"fusion_weight_min": 0.0,
"train_step": 1000,
"use_gray": true
}
},
"12": {
"class_type": "FluxGuidance",
"inputs": {
"conditioning": [
"4",
0
],
"guidance": 3.5
}
},
"13": {
"class_type": "KSampler",
"inputs": {
"model": [
"11",
0
],
"positive": [
"12",
0
],
"negative": [
"5",
0
],
"latent_image": [
"6",
0
],
"seed": 101001,
"steps": 25,
"cfg": 1.0,
"sampler_name": "euler",
"scheduler": "simple",
"denoise": 1.0
}
},
"14": {
"class_type": "VAEDecode",
"inputs": {
"samples": [
"13",
0
],
"vae": [
"3",
0
]
}
},
"15": {
"class_type": "SaveImage",
"inputs": {
"images": [
"14",
0
],
"filename_prefix": "m103_clean_r1_1_pulid_w085"
}
}
}

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,165 @@
{
"1": {
"class_type": "UnetLoaderGGUF",
"inputs": {
"unet_name": "flux1-dev-Q5_K_S.gguf"
}
},
"2": {
"class_type": "DualCLIPLoader",
"inputs": {
"clip_name1": "clip_l.safetensors",
"clip_name2": "t5xxl_fp8_e4m3fn.safetensors",
"type": "flux"
}
},
"3": {
"class_type": "VAELoader",
"inputs": {
"vae_name": "ae.safetensors"
}
},
"4": {
"class_type": "CLIPTextEncode",
"inputs": {
"text": "A 25-28 year old Korean woman in a modern hanbok with subtle Cute Horror mood, sitting gracefully in a traditional Korean tea house with hanok wooden architecture, warm afternoon light filtering through latticed windows, cool pale skin, gentle expression, photorealistic, high detail",
"clip": [
"2",
0
]
}
},
"5": {
"class_type": "CLIPTextEncode",
"inputs": {
"text": "cartoon, anime, child, teenage, purple hoodie, japanese building, plastic skin",
"clip": [
"2",
0
]
}
},
"6": {
"class_type": "EmptyLatentImage",
"inputs": {
"width": 768,
"height": 1344,
"batch_size": 1
}
},
"7": {
"class_type": "PulidFluxModelLoader",
"inputs": {
"pulid_file": "pulid_flux_v0.9.1.safetensors"
}
},
"8": {
"class_type": "PulidFluxEvaClipLoader",
"inputs": {}
},
"9": {
"class_type": "PulidFluxInsightFaceLoader",
"inputs": {
"provider": "CUDA"
}
},
"10": {
"class_type": "LoadImage",
"inputs": {
"image": "byeolyi-ref-768x1344.png"
}
},
"11": {
"class_type": "ApplyPulidFlux",
"inputs": {
"model": [
"1",
0
],
"pulid_flux": [
"7",
0
],
"eva_clip": [
"8",
0
],
"face_analysis": [
"9",
0
],
"image": [
"10",
0
],
"weight": 1.0,
"start_at": 0.0,
"end_at": 0.8,
"fusion": "mean",
"fusion_weight_max": 1.0,
"fusion_weight_min": 0.0,
"train_step": 1000,
"use_gray": true
}
},
"12": {
"class_type": "FluxGuidance",
"inputs": {
"conditioning": [
"4",
0
],
"guidance": 3.5
}
},
"13": {
"class_type": "KSampler",
"inputs": {
"model": [
"11",
0
],
"positive": [
"12",
0
],
"negative": [
"5",
0
],
"latent_image": [
"6",
0
],
"seed": 101003,
"steps": 25,
"cfg": 1.0,
"sampler_name": "euler",
"scheduler": "simple",
"denoise": 1.0
}
},
"14": {
"class_type": "VAEDecode",
"inputs": {
"samples": [
"13",
0
],
"vae": [
"3",
0
]
}
},
"15": {
"class_type": "SaveImage",
"inputs": {
"images": [
"14",
0
],
"filename_prefix": "m103_clean_r1_3_pulid_w100"
}
}
}

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,210 @@
{
"1": {
"class_type": "UnetLoaderGGUF",
"inputs": {
"unet_name": "flux1-dev-Q5_K_S.gguf"
}
},
"2": {
"class_type": "DualCLIPLoader",
"inputs": {
"clip_name1": "clip_l.safetensors",
"clip_name2": "t5xxl_fp8_e4m3fn.safetensors",
"type": "flux"
}
},
"3": {
"class_type": "VAELoader",
"inputs": {
"vae_name": "ae.safetensors"
}
},
"4": {
"class_type": "CLIPTextEncode",
"inputs": {
"text": "A 25-28 year old Korean woman in a modern hanbok with subtle Cute Horror mood, sitting gracefully in a traditional Korean tea house with hanok wooden architecture, warm afternoon light filtering through latticed windows, cool pale skin, gentle expression, photorealistic, high detail",
"clip": [
"2",
0
]
}
},
"5": {
"class_type": "CLIPTextEncode",
"inputs": {
"text": "cartoon, anime, child, teenage, purple hoodie, japanese building, plastic skin",
"clip": [
"2",
0
]
}
},
"6": {
"class_type": "EmptyLatentImage",
"inputs": {
"width": 768,
"height": 1344,
"batch_size": 1
}
},
"7": {
"class_type": "PulidFluxModelLoader",
"inputs": {
"pulid_file": "pulid_flux_v0.9.1.safetensors"
}
},
"8": {
"class_type": "PulidFluxEvaClipLoader",
"inputs": {}
},
"9": {
"class_type": "PulidFluxInsightFaceLoader",
"inputs": {
"provider": "CUDA"
}
},
"10": {
"class_type": "LoadImage",
"inputs": {
"image": "byeolyi-ref-768x1344.png"
}
},
"11": {
"class_type": "ApplyPulidFlux",
"inputs": {
"model": [
"1",
0
],
"pulid_flux": [
"7",
0
],
"eva_clip": [
"8",
0
],
"face_analysis": [
"9",
0
],
"image": [
"10",
0
],
"weight": 0.7,
"start_at": 0.0,
"end_at": 0.8,
"fusion": "mean",
"fusion_weight_max": 1.0,
"fusion_weight_min": 0.0,
"train_step": 1000,
"use_gray": true
}
},
"12": {
"class_type": "FluxGuidance",
"inputs": {
"conditioning": [
"19",
0
],
"guidance": 3.5
}
},
"13": {
"class_type": "KSampler",
"inputs": {
"model": [
"11",
0
],
"positive": [
"12",
0
],
"negative": [
"5",
0
],
"latent_image": [
"6",
0
],
"seed": 101004,
"steps": 25,
"cfg": 1.0,
"sampler_name": "euler",
"scheduler": "simple",
"denoise": 1.0
}
},
"14": {
"class_type": "VAEDecode",
"inputs": {
"samples": [
"13",
0
],
"vae": [
"3",
0
]
}
},
"15": {
"class_type": "SaveImage",
"inputs": {
"images": [
"14",
0
],
"filename_prefix": "m103_clean_r1_4_pulid_redux"
}
},
"16": {
"class_type": "StyleModelLoader",
"inputs": {
"style_model_name": "flux1-redux-dev.safetensors"
}
},
"17": {
"class_type": "CLIPVisionLoader",
"inputs": {
"clip_name": "sigclip_vision_patch14_384.safetensors"
}
},
"18": {
"class_type": "CLIPVisionEncode",
"inputs": {
"clip_vision": [
"17",
0
],
"image": [
"10",
0
],
"crop": "center"
}
},
"19": {
"class_type": "StyleModelApply",
"inputs": {
"conditioning": [
"4",
0
],
"style_model": [
"16",
0
],
"clip_vision_output": [
"18",
0
],
"strength": 0.5,
"strength_type": "multiply"
}
}
}