meeting-103 v2.1 clean — R1~R8 그리드

총 40 조합 / 성공 33 · 8 라운드 완료

🏆 전체 best pastel: R8-8-5 R6-2 baseline + dpmpp_2m karras = 82.43%
라운드별 best: R1: 48.50% / R2: 49.99% / R3: 77.30% / R4: 56.41% / R5: 49.85% / R6: 69.66% / R7: 65.93% / R8: 82.43%
R9 legacy 44.5% → R1 48.5% → R2 49.99% → R3 50.47% → R4 56.41% → R6 69.66% → R8 82.43% (총 +37.93pp)
⭐ 발견 1: byeolyi-default.png ref가 byeolyi-ref-768x1344.png 보다 우월 (R6-2 +13pp)
⭐ 발견 2: dpmpp_2m karras sampler가 euler/simple 보다 우월 (R8-5 +13pp)
⚠ vision 검수 대기 (별이≥8 / 한자≥4.5 / 한옥≥4.5) — auto 지표는 proxy
1-1
R1-1-1: A — PuLID weight 0.85 mean (first try)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux
pastel=25.65% / black=1.95%
clean
1-2
R1-1-2: A — PuLID weight 0.85 mean delayed_start 0.05 (concat-replacement)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux
pastel=9.99% / black=13.98%
black-suspiciouspastel-low
1-3
R1-1-3: A — PuLID weight 1.0 mean
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux
pastel=27.51% / black=0.79%
clean
1-4
R1-1-4: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.5
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=48.5% / black=0.27%
clean
1-5
R1-1-5: B — Hanok baseline Flux Dev 768²
models=flux-dev
pastel=12.87% / black=11.67%
black-suspicious
2-1
R2-2-1: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.5 + Stage 3 Refiner (denoise 0.3)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux, flux-dev-refiner
pastel=48.82% / black=0.34%
clean
2-2
R2-2-2: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.7
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=48.93% / black=0.46%
clean
2-3
R2-2-3: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.3
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=38.52% / black=0.48%
clean
2-4
R2-2-4: A — PuLID 0.85 + Redux 0.5
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=49.99% / black=0.18%
clean
2-5
R2-2-5: B — Hanok spring variant (cherry blossom)
models=flux-dev
pastel=44.45% / black=4.3%
clean
3-1
R3-3-1: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.85
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=50.47% / black=0.24%
clean
3-2
R3-3-2: A — PuLID 0.6 + Redux 0.7
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=49.89% / black=0.22%
clean
ERROR
R3-3-3: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.7 @ 1024x1792
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
err: VAEDecode
status-error
3-4
R3-3-4: C — 60갑자 Qwen-Image fp8 + Lightning LoRA 4-step
models=qwen-image-2.0, lightning-lora-qwen
pastel=0.0% / black=100.0%
black-suspiciouspastel-low
3-5
R3-3-5: A — Pony V6 img2img from byeolyi-ref (denoise 0.65)
models=pony-v6
pastel=77.3% / black=0.03%
clean
4-1
R4-4-1: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 1.0 (max)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=56.41% / black=0.2%
clean
4-2
R4-4-2: A — PuLID 0.85 + Redux 0.7 (combine best)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=50.36% / black=0.86%
clean
ERROR
R4-4-3: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 0.85 + Stage 3 Refiner
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux, flux-dev-refiner
err: ApplyPulidFlux
status-error
4-4
R4-4-4: C — 60갑자 Qwen-Image fp8 + Lightning LoRA (lcm/normal cfg=1)
models=qwen-image-2.0, lightning-lora-qwen
pastel=0.0% / black=100.0%
black-suspiciouspastel-low
4-5
R4-4-5: B — Hanok summer (green pines, blue sky)
models=flux-dev
pastel=17.72% / black=3.97%
clean
5-1
R5-5-1: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 1.0 + Stage 3 Refiner (denoise 0.25)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux, flux-dev-refiner
pastel=49.85% / black=0.08%
clean
ERROR
R5-5-2: A — PuLID 0.5 + Redux 1.0
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
err: ApplyPulidFlux
status-error
ERROR
R5-5-3: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 1.0 strength_type=attn_bias
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
err: ApplyPulidFlux
status-error
5-4
R5-5-4: C — 60갑자 Qwen fp8 full 25-step euler/normal cfg=2.5 (no Lightning LoRA)
models=qwen-image-2.0
pastel=0.0% / black=100.0%
black-suspiciouspastel-low
5-5
R5-5-5: B — Hanok winter (snow)
models=flux-dev
pastel=48.65% / black=3.7%
clean
6-1
R6-6-1: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 1.0 (ref byeolyi-916.png)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=52.99% / black=0.5%
clean
6-2
R6-6-2: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 1.0 (ref byeolyi-default.png)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=69.66% / black=0.05%
clean
ERROR
R6-6-3: A — PuLID 0.7 + multi-Redux (ref 1344+default)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
err: ApplyPulidFlux
status-error
6-4
R6-6-4: C — 60갑자 Qwen fp8 + ModelSamplingAuraFlow shift=3.0
models=qwen-image-2.0
pastel=0.0% / black=100.0%
black-suspiciouspastel-low
6-5
R6-6-5: B — Hanok dancheong (red blue green eaves)
models=flux-dev
pastel=15.09% / black=12.46%
black-suspicious
7-1
R7-7-1: A — PuLID 0.85 + Redux 1.0 (default ref)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=64.45% / black=0.01%
clean
7-2
R7-7-2: A — PuLID 0.6 + Redux 1.0 (default ref)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=65.93% / black=0.19%
clean
ERROR
R7-7-3: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 1.0 (default ref, seed 999777)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
err: ApplyPulidFlux
status-error
ERROR
R7-7-4: A — PuLID 0.7 + Redux 1.0 + Stage 3 (denoise 0.20)
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux, flux-dev-refiner
err: ApplyPulidFlux
status-error
7-5
R7-7-5: C — 60갑자 Pony V6 calligraphy prompt
models=pony-v6
pastel=18.09% / black=0.02%
clean
8-1
R8-8-1: A — R6-2 baseline seed 200000
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=65.73% / black=0.03%
clean
8-2
R8-8-2: A — R6-2 baseline seed 555555
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=64.3% / black=0.05%
clean
8-3
R8-8-3: A — R6-2 baseline + guidance 2.5
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=62.71% / black=0.0%
clean
8-4
R8-8-4: A — R6-2 baseline + guidance 5.0
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=69.99% / black=0.47%
clean
8-5
R8-8-5 🏆: A — R6-2 baseline + dpmpp_2m karras
models=flux-dev, pulid-flux, flux-redux
pastel=82.43% / black=0.0%
clean